Hello everyone. I have the complex number (1 - E^2) (2 + I 2 Pi k) with k integer. How can I get the general formula for the argument? It should be Pi+ArcTan[k Pi] if k>0.
I tried with:
Assumptions->Element[k,Integers]
Assumptions -> k > 0
Arg[(1 - E^2) (2 I Pi k)]
but it does not work.
Thank you very much.
This gives an idea
In[18]:= Arg[-2 - I # \[Pi]] & /@ Range[10]
Out[18]= {-\[Pi] + ArcTan[\[Pi]/2], -\[Pi] + ArcTan[\[Pi]], -\[Pi] + ArcTan[(3 \[Pi])/2],
-\[Pi] + ArcTan[2 \[Pi]], -\[Pi] + ArcTan[(5 \[Pi])/2],-\[Pi] + ArcTan[3 \[Pi]],
-\[Pi] + ArcTan[(7 \[Pi])/2], -\[Pi] + ArcTan[4 \[Pi]],-\[Pi] + ArcTan[(9 \[Pi])/2],
-\[Pi] + ArcTan[5 \[Pi]]}
but here you see a rational positive k does it as well
In[24]:= FindInstance[Arg[-2 - I k \[Pi]] == -\[Pi] + ArcTan[k \[Pi]/2], {k}]
Out[24]= {{k -> 106/5}}
why not compute it directly, it’s just plane trigonometry.
Because of Numeric Quantities and Arg
Arg[z] is left unevaluated if z is not a numeric quantity.
one has
In[15]:= Arg[-2 - I GoldenRatio \[Pi]]
Out[15]= -\[Pi] + ArcTan[(GoldenRatio \[Pi])/2]
but (because x is not a numeric quantity)
In[31]:= Simplify[Arg[-2 - I \[Pi] x], x \[Element] Reals && x > 0]
Out[31]= Arg[-2 - I \[Pi] x]
the assumption x > 0 does not constitute x as numeric quantity.
danl
(Daniel Lichtblau)
February 6, 2018, 5:09pm
4
Could use Refine in tandem with ComplexExpand. The latter assumes variables take on real values unless instructed otherwise.
Refine[
ComplexExpand[Arg[(1 - E^2) (2 + I 2 Pi k)],
TargetFunctions -> {Re, Im}], k \[Element] Reals && k > 0]
(* Out[624]= -\[Pi] + ArcTan[k \[Pi]] *)