Message Boards Message Boards

Avoid conflict problem with the standard package MultivariateStatistics?

Claude Mante, Retired
Posted 7 years ago

Hi everybody!

I'm trying to execute again an old notebook using simultaneously "MultinormalDistribution", "EllipsoidQuantile" and "SpatialMedian", and it doesn't work any more. Here is a short example.

Clear["Global`*"];

Needs["MultivariateStatistics`"];
dist = MultinormalDistribution[{0, 
    0}, {{1.7632655763946026`, -1.6637745757032427`}, \
{-1.6637745757032427`, 3.2291056091906434`}}];

Bad sign: MultinormalDistribution is red (more than one context, etc.)...

Something from the documentation:

EllipsoidProbability[dist, EllipsoidQuantile[dist, .5]]

0.5: OK. Now let's process a sample:

ech = RandomVariate[dist, 500];
Mean@ech
SpatialMedian[ech]

Nothing abnormal, but SpatialMedian is red, too... Now, another example from the documentation, adapted to my data:

{{minx, maxx}, {miny, 
   maxy}} = ({Min[#], Max[#]} &) /@ {First@Transpose@ech, 
   Last@Transpose@ech}
q = EllipsoidQuartiles[ech];
Graphics[q, Frame -> True, AspectRatio -> 1, 
 PlotRange -> {{minx, maxx}, {miny, maxy}}]

No plot, but a nice pink window with the message:

Charting`Private`Tag$2889#1 is not a Graphics primitive or directive.

What should I do?

Best regards, Claude
POSTED BY: Claude Mante
2 Replies
Sort By:

Dear Gokul,

thanks a lot for reminding me of the existence of contexts!

Needs["MultivariateStatistics`"]
dist = System`MultinormalDistribution[{0, 0},
   {{1.7632655763946026`, -1.6637745757032427`}, \
{-1.6637745757032427`, 3.2291056091906434`}}];
ech = RandomReal[dist, 500];
Mean@ech
System`SpatialMedian[ech]
{{minx, maxx}, {miny, 
   maxy}} = ({Min[#], Max[#]} &) /@ {First@Transpose@ech, 
   Last@Transpose@ech}

works perfectly. Nevetheless, on my machine (Mathematica version 11.1)

Graphics[EllipsoidQuartiles[ech]]

results in an error and I have to use Map to obtain something correct:

Show[ListPlot[ech, PlotRange -> All], 
 Map[Graphics, EllipsoidQuartiles[ech]], Frame -> True]

I didn't met this problem with earlier versions, as far as I remember.

Claude
POSTED BY: Claude Mante

Hi, Find a notebook attached with everything worked out. Graphics may depend on the PC; it works for me in a Windows PC with Intel graphics. MultinormalDistribution is a system function from Mathematica 8 onwards, specifying that helps. Also, you need to use RandomReal, and not RandomVariate in this context.

Attachments:
POSTED BY: Gokul Hariharan
Reply to this discussion
Community posts can be styled and formatted using the Markdown syntax.
Tag limit exceeded
Note: Only the first five people you tag will receive an email notification; the other tagged names will appear as links to their profiles.
Reply Preview
Attachments
Remove
or Discard

Group Abstract Group Abstract