Message Boards Message Boards

0
|
7547 Views
|
5 Replies
|
4 Total Likes
View groups...
Share
Share this post:

Limit problem from "Mean girls" TV program?

Posted 5 years ago

I watched mean girls recently and i got interested in the math problem presented. evaluate the limit:

(lim)(x?0)  ( ln?(1-x)-sin?x)/(1-cos^2?x )

enter image description here

One girl got the answer -1, which was wrong. The main character reached the right answer in 13 seconds, the limit does not exist. What intrigues me is what different ways could this be solved? How can you reach the answer in 13 seconds, and how did the other girl get -1?

POSTED BY: ingrid schau
5 Replies
Posted 5 years ago

Interesting. Applying LHopital's rule twice gives -1/2:

expr = (Log[1 - x] - Sin[x])/(1 - Cos[x]^2);

d2num = D[Numerator[expr], {x, 2}]

(* -(1/(1-x)^2)+Sin[x] *)

d2denom = D[Denominator[expr], {x, 2}]

(* 2 Cos[x]^2-2 Sin[x]^2 *)

d2num/d2denom /. x -> 0

(* -(1/2) *)

But this is not correct, so LHopital's rule must arrive at an indeterminate form. But why is this indeterminate?

POSTED BY: David Keith

Recalling an admonition to mind the signs, the first derivative of the numerator does not vanish at 0. So you don't (sob) get to apply a second time.

POSTED BY: Daniel Lichtblau
Posted 5 years ago

Yes! I had forgotten that! Thanks, Daniel

POSTED BY: David Keith

If the minus in the numerator became a plus, and the square in the denom term was lost, that would give -1. Offhand i do not see a way to get that result with only one typography change.

POSTED BY: Daniel Lichtblau

Here are three methods:

(1) Plug it into Wolfram|Alpha.

(2) Plug it into Mathematica.

Or the off-topic response, (3) use Taylor series and don't mess up the signs like I did at first.

POSTED BY: Michael Rogers
Reply to this discussion
Community posts can be styled and formatted using the Markdown syntax.
Reply Preview
Attachments
Remove
or Discard

Group Abstract Group Abstract