Message Boards Message Boards


Temperature evolution differ in two models while it should be the same

Posted 19 days ago
0 Replies
0 Total Likes

I'm trying to model the heat teansfer of an object with cross sectional shape of a 25mm by 25mm square. The top and bottom surface are insulated, so only the side dessipates heat convectively. In the Mathematica code I first tried non-dimensionalize the 2D heat equation but with the time variable unchanged, and then I also tried non-dimensionalize the time variable. These two approach gives me different modeling results, can someone help me take a look of my code and give me some insight? Really appreciated! The two governing equations I used are listed here for reference:

with dimensional time variable: D[θ[t, ξ, ψ], t] - αmodified*(D[θ[t, ξ, ψ], {ξ, 2}] + D[θ[t, ξ, ψ], {ψ, 2}]) dimensionless time variable: D[θ[tau, ξ, ψ], tau] -(D[θ[tau, ξ, ψ], {ξ, 2}] + D[θ[tau, ξ, ψ], {ψ, 2}])

the dimensionless temperature θ=(T-T∞)/(T0-T∞), dimensionless width=x/L, L is the side length of object, equals 25mm, same for dimensionless length ψ=y/L

To make the problem more clear, here's two image, modeled at position ξ = 0.85, ψ = 0.85, the temperature curve from the model with/without dimensionless time looks significantly different although it's all plotted for the real time 0 to 20 sec.
with dimensional time enter image description here

with dimensionless time enter image description here

you can tell the temperature evolution is very very different, which in theory they shouldn't

Reply to this discussion
Community posts can be styled and formatted using the Markdown syntax.
Reply Preview
or Discard

Group Abstract Group Abstract