Group Abstract Group Abstract

Message Boards Message Boards

0
|
6.2K Views
|
4 Replies
|
0 Total Likes
View groups...
Share
Share this post:

Need help with constructing Loops

Hi I have a problem when constructing For loops. My simple code are as below

For[ i=1 , i < 12 , i = i+2,  f[ i_ ] := i * 9 ]

I want the result will be only exist when I enter

f[1] =9i, f[3]=27i,  f[5]=45i till f[11]=99i

only

However, the results are for all values of i.

Anybody can explain why is that happening?
POSTED BY: Syed Muhammad Hilmi Syed Anera
4 Replies
Sort By:

But f[i] is not a list. These are indexed objects (also called Array in Mathematica). I was talking about normal lists, which I understood what the OP was trying to make, which is indexed by [[ ]] and not by []

MakingDefinitionsForIndexedObjects.html

You can define a list, say , then access its elements using , or modify them using . This approach has a drawback, however, in that it requires you to fill in all the elements when you first create the list.

So in a list, one has to have value in each index. But not for indexed objects (or Array). If OP wanted array, then ofcourse they do not need to fill in each entry. Sometimes it is hard to know what OP is asking when code presented does not work at all.
POSTED BY: Nasser M. Abbasi

But f[i] is not a list.

Of course not: The problem owner neither uses the word list nor does (s)he use list syntax like f[[i]]. Possibly an associative array is meant:

In[1]:= Clear[f]
For[i = 1, i < 12, i += 2, f[i] = 9 i]

In[4]:= Table[f[o], {o, 1, 12}]
Out[4]= {9, f[2], 27, f[4], 45, f[6], 63, f[8], 81, f[10], 99, f[12]}

Now problem owners code appears to contain only two incorrect characters: : and _. But that does not reproduce problem owners example. If (s)he really wants the i printed in the results, (s)he could do

In[5]:= Clear[f, i]
For[o = 1, o < 12, o += 2, f[o] = 9 o i]

In[7]:= Table[f[k], {k, 1, 12}]
Out[7]= {9 i, f[2], 27 i, f[4], 45 i, f[6], 63 i, f[8], 81 i, f[10], 99 i, f[12]}

This implicit i can be considered as bad style, so write explicitly

In[20]:= Clear[f,x]
For[i = 1, i < 12, i += 2, f[i, x_] = 9 i x]

In[26]:= Clear[i]
Table[f[k, i], {k, 1, 12}]
Out[27]= {9 i, f[2, i], 27 i, f[4, i], 45 i, f[6, i], 63 i, f[8, i], 81 i, f[10, i], 99 i, f[12, i]}

if one does not clear the i it has value 13 and the result looks strange. Preferable

Clear[f]
f[i_ /; OddQ[i] && 1 <= i <= 11, x_] := 9 i x
POSTED BY: Udo Krause

You can't have a list that contain entries for only some index values.

You can, but the definition needed has nothing to do with For loops at all.

In[2]:= f[i_ /; OddQ[i] && 1 <= i <= 11] := 9 i

In[3]:= f[2]
Out[3]= f[2]

In[4]:= f[3]
Out[4]= 27

In[5]:= f[11]
Out[5]= 99

In[6]:= f[13]
Out[6]= f[13]

What you wrote

For[ i=1 , i < 12 , i = i+2,  f[ i_ ] := i * 9 ]

is plainly wrong: if taken literally it reads for $i=1$ as f[1_]:= 1 * 9 and there is no possibility to have the number $1$ as variable or placeholder.
POSTED BY: Udo Krause 
f[1] =9i, f[3]=27i,  f[5]=45i till f[11]=99i

You can't have a list that contain entries for only some index values. So, what should be in f[2] and f[5]? It has to contain something, even if it was Null or {}

Using For is not recommended. You can use Table, much better. Also make sure you know the difference between = and :=
POSTED BY: Nasser M. Abbasi
Reply to this discussion
Community posts can be styled and formatted using the Markdown syntax.
Tag limit exceeded
Note: Only the first five people you tag will receive an email notification; the other tagged names will appear as links to their profiles.
Reply Preview
Attachments
Remove
or Discard