Message Boards Message Boards


No output from Solve[ ]?

Posted 5 months ago
1 Reply
0 Total Likes

Could someone please look at this and tell me what's wrong? It's probably a simple mistake. I think this system of equations should return {{pd -> -3}, {pd -> 10}}. At least, that's what I get when I use a pencil and paper. But my input below doesn't return anything. Not even an error message.

The solution set is more complicated than that:

Reduce[(js + ps) 6 == w && js (pd + 5) == w && ps pd == w, 
  Reals] // LogicalExpand

I don't know the exact reason why Solve gives an empty set in that special case, but with slight changes in syntax we get meaningful answers:

eqs = (js + ps) 6 == w && js (pd + 5) == w && ps pd == w;
Solve[eqs, Reals]
Solve[eqs, {pd, w, ps, js}, Reals]
Reply to this discussion
Community posts can be styled and formatted using the Markdown syntax.
Reply Preview
or Discard

Group Abstract Group Abstract