Message Boards Message Boards

Polygon Dissections

Posted 9 months ago

Polygon Dissections
There are currently 422 dissections at the Wolfram Demonstrations site, so I thought I'd give a talk about them. Here are the records as they stand at Gavin Theobald's Polygon Dissections.

enter image description here
I was also recently intrigued by Quanta's Animation for a six fractal piece square to circle dissection by Andras Máthé, Oleg Pikhurko and Jonathan Noel. enter image description here

The following code shows two polygons with the same unit area.

UnitAreaPolyPoints[k_, angle_ : 0] := 
  CirclePoints[{Sqrt[2] Sqrt[Csc[(2 \[Pi])/k]/k], angle }, k];
Manipulate[Graphics[{
   Line[Append[#, First[#]] &@UnitAreaPolyPoints[j, anglej]],
   Line[Append[#, First[#]] &@UnitAreaPolyPoints[k, anglek]]}],
 {{j, 3}, 3, 12, 1}, {{k, 5}, 3, 12, 1},
 {{anglej, 0}, -Pi, Pi}, {{anglek, 0}, -Pi, Pi}, 
 SaveDefinitions -> True, SynchronousInitialization -> False]

With this, it's possible to prove that a triangle to square dissection requires at least 3 pieces.

New we can start showing dissections. Triangle to Square.

ResourceFunction["CreditedDemonstration"]["EquilateralTriangleToSquare"]
ResourceFunction["CreditedDemonstration"]["HaberdashersProblem"]
ResourceFunction["CreditedDemonstration"]["AnExampleOfTheBolyaiGerwienTheorem"]
ResourceFunction["CreditedDemonstration"]["DissectionOfASphericalTriangleIntoASquare"]

enter image description here

Triangle to Pentagon ResourceFunction["CreditedDemonstration"]["GoldbergsPentagonToTriangleDissection"] We can also get close, as in Pentagon-to-Near-Equilateral-Triangle Dissection. enter image description here

Triangle to Hexagon ResourceFunction["CreditedDemonstration"]["LindgrensHexagonToTriangleDissection"]

Triangle to Heptagon Theobald's Dissection of a Heptagon to a Triangle

Triangle to Octagon Theobald's Dissection of an Octagon into a Triangle enter image description here

Triangle to Nonagon Theobald's Nonagon-to-Triangle Dissection and Hanegraaf's Dissection of a Nonagon into a Triangle. enter image description here

All of these can be laser cut or 3D printed, as shown by Izidor Hafner. enter image description here

Square to Pentagon Freese's Dissection of a Regular Pentagon to a Square enter image description here

ResourceFunction["CreditedDemonstration"]["BrodiesPentagonToSquareDissection"]
ResourceFunction["CreditedDemonstration"]["PentagonToNearSquareDissection"]

Adam Gsellman: Pentagon to rectangle is 4. enter image description here

Square to Hexagon Busschop's Hexagon-to-Square Dissection

ResourceFunction["CreditedDemonstration"]["BradleysHexagramToSquareDissection"]

enter image description here

Square to Heptagon Theobald's Heptagon-to-Square Dissection enter image description here

Square to Octagon Bennett's Octagon-to-Square Dissection enter image description here

Square to Nonagon Theobald's Nonagon-to-Square Dissection enter image description here

Square to Decagon Decagon-to-Square Dissection enter image description here

Square to Dodecagon Freese's Dissection of a Regular Dodecagon into a Square Lindgren's Square-to-Dodecagon Dissection enter image description here

Pentagon to Hexagon Lindgren's Dissection of a Pentagon to a Hexagon

Pentagon to Heptagon Theobald's Dissection of a Heptagon to a Pentagon

Hexagon to Heptagon Theobald's Heptagon-to-Hexagon Dissection enter image description here

Hexagon to Dodecagon Dodecagon-to-Hexagon Dissection enter image description here

That shows quite a few ways of transforming one polygon into another. It's also possible to take multiple copies of a polygon and make a larger version of the same polygon.

ResourceFunction["CreditedDemonstration"]["DissectionOfOneRegularHeptagonIntoSeven"]
ResourceFunction["CreditedDemonstration"]["DissectionOfARegularHeptagonIntoEight"]
ResourceFunction["CreditedDemonstration"]["DissectionOfARegularDodecagonIntoThree"]
ResourceFunction["CreditedDemonstration"]["DissectionOfARegularDodecagonIntoSixSmallerOnes"]

enter image description here

Regular polygons with an edge length of 2 have some odd properties.
1. What is the area of the annulus?
2. What is the square distance sum between vertex heights?

The results of Shattering the Plane came out of a simple question: how can similar triangles surround a point? So far, this question hasn't been answered in 3D with tetrahedra. enter image description here That particular dissection leads to the following substitution tiling: enter image description here

Wallace[Dash]Bolyai[Dash]Gerwien theorem: Two polygons of the same area can be dissected into each other. Discovered independently by Wallace: 1807, Bolyai: 1833, Gerwein: 1835. Hilbert's 3rd problem asked about 3D. Max Dehn solved the problem: No. He proved you can't cut a regular tetrahedron into pieces to make a cube. Polyhedra of the same volume are Scissors Congruent iff they have the same Dehn Invariant. It turns out that the Engel-38 polyhedron has Dehn invariance 0.

There are 3D dissections. Hanegraaf's Rectangular Block of Size 211 to a Cube Dissection enter image description here

Most dissections lack minimality proofs!

hexy = CirclePoints[6];
Graphics[{Line[Join[hexy, {hexy[[1]], hexy[[3]], Mean[{hexy[[1]], hexy[[3]]}], hexy[[2]]}]]}]

enter image description here

For example, above, a hexagon is divided into 3 pieces to make a rectangle. Is there a proof that 2 pieces isn't enough for cutting a hexagon into a rectangle?

POSTED BY: Ed Pegg
Reply to this discussion
Community posts can be styled and formatted using the Markdown syntax.
Reply Preview
Attachments
Remove
or Discard

Group Abstract Group Abstract