Message Boards Message Boards

0
|
10134 Views
|
4 Replies
|
3 Total Likes
View groups...
Share
Share this post:

Using "If" statement here?

David Kirkby
Posted 8 years ago

I have some electronic connectors with one being male and the other being female. The connectors have 5 coefficients associated with them, which have different numerical values for the males and females. I want to do some processing based on the sex of the connector. The 5 parameters are:

offsetDelayps 
C0
C1
C2
C3

offsetDelayps should be 55.1 for a male connector, but 39.8 for a female. C0 for should be 50.389 for a male connector, but 53.004 for a female etc. I want to set the appropriate values of the coefficients, based on whether the sex of the connector is male or female. So I tried this "If" statement, but after printing the value of offsetDelayps, it is always 55.1 (the male value) and never 39.8 (the female value). In the code below, the sex is set to female, so the If statement should evaluate to "False", to the data after the comma (False values) should I think be set differently. 

n[43]:= sex = female;
In[44]:= If[sex == male, offsetDelayps = 55.1 ; C0 = 50.389 ; 
  C1 = 761.36; C2 = -968.22; C3 = 68.376, offsetDelayps = 39.8; 
  C0 = 53.004; C1 = 135.167; C2 = 95.6305; C3 = 30.937];

In[45]:= offsetDelayps
Out[45]= 55.1

The values of 5 parameters are always set to the male values, and never the female ones, despite the "If" statement should evaluate to false when the sex is set to anything other than male. In the above code, offsetDelayps should, I believer, be set to 39.8 for female, but it is always set to 55.1, irrespective of what I set the sex to.

Any ideas what I'm doing wrong? Any ideas how to set the values properly?

Attachments:
POSTED BY: David Kirkby
4 Replies
Sort By:

You can also avoid using conditionals and global variables by just putting your coefficients in an association:

coeff =
 <| "male" -> <|"offsetDelayps" -> 55.1, "C0" -> 50.389,  "C1" -> 761.36 , "C2" -> -968.22,  "C3" -> 68.376|>,
  "female" -> <|"offsetDelayps" -> 39.8, "C0" -> 53.004,  "C1" -> 135.167, "C2" ->  95.6305, "C3" -> 30.937|>|>

Then just get the value you need like

In[2]:= coeff["male", "offsetDelayps"]

Out[2]= 55.1


In[3]:= coeff["female", "C3"]

Out[3]= 30.937
POSTED BY: Gustavo Delfino
David Kirkby
David Kirkby
Posted 8 years ago

Thank you both. I was not aware of the === operator. I was only aware of the = and == operators.

I guess an advantage of the Switch command over the If command, is that if I make a typo, and mean to set the sex to male, but accidentally set it to mole (or some other typo), the variables will not get set, so all the processing will go wrong and it will be obvious there's a problem.

POSTED BY: David Kirkby
Hans Milton
Hans Milton
Posted 8 years ago

Further to Biancas suggestion to use strings:

In[1]:= sex = "female";

In[2]:= Switch[sex,
  "male",
    offsetDelayps = 55.1;
    C0 = 50.389,
  "female",
    offsetDelayps = 39.8;
    C0 = 53.004
];

In[3]:= offsetDelayps
        C0

Out[3]= 39.8

Out[4]= 53.004
POSTED BY: Hans Milton

Hi David, your problem stems from the use of symbols for male and female. Mathematica can't know what kind of a value a symbol may aquire down the line, so sex==male is simply not determined. Try evaluating the following:

sex=female;
sex==male
sex===male

As you can see, the second line simply doesn't know if your statement is True or False. The last line (with three equal signs, i.e. SameQ) does what you want because it treats undecided cases as False. However, the cleaner alternative would be to work with strings:

sex="female";
sex=="male"

This way, nothing can go wrong even if you accidentally assign a value to male or female eventually.
POSTED BY: Bianca Eifert
Reply to this discussion
Community posts can be styled and formatted using the Markdown syntax.
Tag limit exceeded
Note: Only the first five people you tag will receive an email notification; the other tagged names will appear as links to their profiles.
Reply Preview
Attachments
Remove
or Discard

Group Abstract Group Abstract