Version 9 does not treat the second form usefully, so the new, Entity interpretation is used in WPC.
In[1]:= ElementData[6,"AtomicMass"]
Out[1]= 12.0107
In[2]:= ElementData[6]["AtomicMass"]
Out[2]= Carbon[AtomicMass]
ElementData and other functions will be billed consistently with other data-retrieval functions like EntityValue. For the time being these functions are not billing when used the v9 way, as a courtesy to users who have used these functions in the old ways in previous versions.
Please note that it will not cost Cloud Credits to make these calls in Mathematica 10, when released.