Group Abstract Group Abstract

«Groups
Presentation and Notebooks
Join
Creating and using notebook documents and slide show presentations.

Discussions List Discussions List

Try to use the Chat-enabled notebook and got an error

QUESTION FROM: Carlos Quintanilla | 2 years ago BY: Yvan Abbe
External Programs and Systems , Presentation and Notebooks , ...
21
REPLIES
14.8K
VIEWS

Conditional Equation in TraditionalForm

QUESTION FROM: Dean Sparrow | 10 years ago BY: Frank Kampas
Mathematica , Mathematics , Presentation and Notebooks , ...
15
REPLIES
9.6K
VIEWS

Fix incorrect DPI setting for rendering fonts in Mathematica ?

QUESTION FROM: Dietmar Rempfer | 6 years ago BY: Tigran Aivazian
Mathematica , Presentation and Notebooks , User Interface
10
REPLIES
18.6K
VIEWS

[?] How to add example links to documentation pages?

QUESTION FROM: Szabolcs Horvát | 8 years ago BY: Brian Van Vertloo
Mathematica , Presentation and Notebooks , User Interface , Workbench
6
REPLIES
17.2K
VIEWS

Sharing Mathematica notebooks with non-Mathematica colleagues?

QUESTION FROM: Paul Nielan | 5 years ago BY: Rolf Mertig
Mathematica , Presentation and Notebooks
10
REPLIES
20.6K
VIEWS

Create (Header + Main area + Settings pane) notebook layout?

QUESTION FROM: Kuba Podkalicki | 7 years ago BY: b3m2a1 ​ 
Mathematica , Presentation and Notebooks , User Interface
5
REPLIES
12.5K
VIEWS

Is there an online library of Mathematica Slideshows created by users?

QUESTION FROM: Yekaterina Gilbo | 8 years ago BY: Yekaterina Gilbo
Authoring and Publishing , Presentation and Notebooks , User Interface
4
REPLIES
13.9K
VIEWS

Version control of Mathematica notebooks to include it in git repositories

QUESTION FROM: Hongyi Zhao | 3 years ago BY: Hongyi Zhao
Presentation and Notebooks , Wolfram Language
30
REPLIES
13.3K
VIEWS

Writing Literate Notebooks

QUESTION FROM: David J M Park Jr | 10 years ago BY: David J M Park Jr
Authoring and Publishing , Education , Mathematica , ...
8
REPLIES
19.4K
VIEWS

Making Wolfram Language content available to the public?

QUESTION FROM: Zafer Gurdal | 2 years ago BY: Zafer Gurdal
Education , Presentation and Notebooks , Wolfram Community , ...
5
REPLIES
4.4K
VIEWS

What is the best way to manage all the small programs you create in MMA?

QUESTION FROM: Andrew Burnett | 6 years ago BY: Andrew Burnett
Mathematica , Presentation and Notebooks , Software Development , ...
27
REPLIES
26.1K
VIEWS

Lost a Notebook with 11.0.1. How to get it again?

QUESTION FROM: Werner Geiger | 8 years ago BY: Werner Geiger
Operating System and Network Access , Presentation and Notebooks , ...
22
REPLIES
21.3K
VIEWS

Constructing multiple choice questions for student notebooks.

QUESTION FROM: W. Craig Carter | 11 years ago BY: Erin Craig
Computer-Based Maths , Education , Interface Construction , ...
8
REPLIES
24.8K
VIEWS

How to convert Mathematica notebook to Jupyter notebooks and vice versa?

QUESTION FROM: virtual mind | 1 year ago BY: Anton Antonov
External Programs and Systems , Presentation and Notebooks , ...
12
REPLIES
15.9K
VIEWS

Natural language computation symbol appears unintentionally in V12.1.1

QUESTION FROM: David Barnes | 5 years ago BY: George Woodrow III
Mathematica , Presentation and Notebooks
18
REPLIES
26.5K
VIEWS

Convert a notebook to LaTeX?

QUESTION FROM: Zhehao Zhang | 5 years ago BY: Mike Besso
External Programs and Systems , Graphics and Visualization , ...
3
REPLIES
11.7K
VIEWS

Notebook to ePub3 Conversion

QUESTION FROM: Jeremy Sykes | 7 years ago BY: Calle E
Authoring and Publishing , External Programs and Systems , ...
1
REPLIES
12.8K
VIEWS

Best way to reuse some code in multiple notebooks?

QUESTION FROM: Anonymous User | 8 years ago BY: Anonymous User
Mathematica , Packages , Presentation and Notebooks , Wolfram Language
23
REPLIES
12.6K
VIEWS

Deploy a dynamic notebook to the Wolfram Cloud?

QUESTION FROM: Jorge Manrique | 8 years ago BY: Imre Pazsit
Presentation and Notebooks , Wolfram Cloud , Wolfram Programming Lab
13
REPLIES
20.7K
VIEWS

[?] How to access clipboard in plain text format?

QUESTION FROM: Szabolcs Horvát | 8 years ago BY: Sander Huisman
Mathematica , Presentation and Notebooks , User Interface , ...
4
REPLIES
6.4K
VIEWS

Saving a notebook as a WL script

QUESTION FROM: David Keith | 3 months ago BY: John Millard
Mathematica , Presentation and Notebooks , Wolfram Language
13
REPLIES
25.9K
VIEWS

Corrupted Mathematica notebook

QUESTION FROM: Dick Seers | 4 years ago BY: Gary Palmer
Mathematica , Presentation and Notebooks , Wolfram Language
6
REPLIES
14.4K
VIEWS

[CALL] Stylesheets Survey

QUESTION FROM: Brady Martin | 7 years ago BY: David J M Park Jr
Events & Media , Mathematica , Presentation and Notebooks , ...
3
REPLIES
10.2K
VIEWS

Strange Mathematica 9 problem

QUESTION FROM: E M | 2 years ago BY: David Talaga
Mathematica , Presentation and Notebooks
8
REPLIES
17.5K
VIEWS

How to fit a Dataset output in a PDF file?

QUESTION FROM: Jürgen Kanz | 4 years ago BY: Sa'di Altamimi
Data Science , Graphics and Visualization , ...
15
REPLIES
13.3K
VIEWS

Display the line number in a mathematica package?

QUESTION FROM: zhu xiaoming | 6 years ago BY: zhu xiaoming
Mathematica , Packages , Presentation and Notebooks , ...
10
REPLIES
14.8K
VIEWS

Run NotebookEvaluate on a "slave" kernel controlled through MathLink?

QUESTION FROM: Szabolcs Horvát | 9 years ago BY: Szabolcs Horvát
Mathematica , Packages , Presentation and Notebooks , User Interface
3
REPLIES
7.5K
VIEWS

Packages and Notebooks as a Databin

QUESTION FROM: Rodrigo Murta | 10 years ago BY: Rodrigo Murta
Data Science , Presentation and Notebooks , Wolfram Cloud , ...
4
REPLIES
9.3K
VIEWS

Is there a way to tag cells and hyperlinks programmatically?

QUESTION FROM: W. Craig Carter | 12 years ago BY: Andre Kuzniarek
Authoring and Publishing , Mathematica , Presentation and Notebooks , ...
3
REPLIES
14.9K
VIEWS

How to turn off Internal self-test in Mathematica 13.2.0.0 ?

QUESTION FROM: Richard Frost | 2 years ago BY: John Fultz
Mathematica , Presentation and Notebooks , Wolfram Language
5
REPLIES
6.2K
VIEWS

Why can't multiline comments be aligned in Mathematica notebook?

QUESTION FROM: Hongyi Zhao | 3 years ago BY: Michael Rogers
Mathematica , Presentation and Notebooks , User Interface , ...
3
REPLIES
6.9K
VIEWS

The 12.3 Front End so unresponsive?

QUESTION FROM: George Wolfe | 3 years ago BY: Daniel Lichtblau
Mathematica , Presentation and Notebooks , User Interface , ...
7
REPLIES
14.8K
VIEWS

Internal self-test errors

QUESTION FROM: Andreas Dumont | 4 years ago BY: Kerry Litvin
Curated Data , Mathematica , Presentation and Notebooks , ...
12
REPLIES
12.4K
VIEWS

How to generate, inherit and modify options to Dataset in Version 12.1

QUESTION FROM: Seth Chandler | 5 years ago BY: Christopher Carlson
Data Science , Mathematica , Presentation and Notebooks , ...
1
REPLIES
8.7K
VIEWS

Touch bar on Macbook inserts invisible characters?

QUESTION FROM: W. Craig Carter | 6 years ago BY: W. Craig Carter
Mathematica , Operating System and Network Access , ...
4
REPLIES
9.1K
VIEWS

[?] Pasting numerical expressions into Input Cells?

QUESTION FROM: David J M Park Jr | 8 years ago BY: David J M Park Jr
Mathematica , Presentation and Notebooks , User Interface , ...
11
REPLIES
10.3K
VIEWS

Manipulating notebooks: Kernel vs Front End

QUESTION FROM: Szabolcs Horvát | 9 years ago BY: John Fultz
Import and Export , Mathematica , Presentation and Notebooks , ...
1
REPLIES
9.4K
VIEWS

A "back button" for hyperlinked cell tags in the FrontEnd?

QUESTION FROM: W. Craig Carter | 10 years ago BY: W. Craig Carter
Mathematica , Presentation and Notebooks , User Interface
2
REPLIES
6.8K
VIEWS

version 10 crashes when opening some notebooks

QUESTION FROM: Nasser M. Abbasi | 11 years ago BY: Marco Thiel
Mathematica , Presentation and Notebooks
5
REPLIES
8.6K
VIEWS

How could I programmatically write results of Show Expression to a file?

QUESTION FROM: W. Craig Carter | 12 years ago BY: William Rummler
Mathematica , Presentation and Notebooks , User Interface
5
REPLIES
7.6K
VIEWS

Specifying the LLM in Chat Notebooks Doesn't "stick"

QUESTION FROM: Jacob Evans | 2 years ago BY: Jacob Evans
Computational Linguistics , Data Science , Machine Learning , ...
4
REPLIES
4.5K
VIEWS

Where to find cases of Wolfram language used in published academic papers?

QUESTION FROM: Jack I Houng | 4 years ago BY: Jack I Houng
Authoring and Publishing , Presentation and Notebooks , ...
5
REPLIES
12.4K
VIEWS

Set the default folder to be that of the notebook?

QUESTION FROM: Jyrki Lahtonen | 5 years ago BY: Jyrki Lahtonen
Mathematica , Presentation and Notebooks
7
REPLIES
12.3K
VIEWS

Computational Thinking - Self-Study, Problem Solving Learning Resources

QUESTION FROM: Alec Titterton | 5 years ago BY: Alec Titterton
Authoring and Publishing , Computer-Based Maths , Education , ...
1
REPLIES
10.4K
VIEWS

Invert colors in graphics created using the drawing palette?

QUESTION FROM: George Hrabovsky | 7 years ago BY: Vitaliy Kaurov
Accessibility , Authoring and Publishing , ...
11
REPLIES
14.4K
VIEWS

Presenter Notebooks broken after Windows 10 update 1803?

QUESTION FROM: Markus Roellig | 7 years ago BY: Frank Etzler
Mathematica , Operating System and Network Access , ...
6
REPLIES
13.8K
VIEWS

Type "*^" in DisplayFormula or Equation cells?

QUESTION FROM: Spencer Fretwell | 8 years ago BY: Szabolcs Horvát
Mathematica , Presentation and Notebooks , User Interface , ...
3
REPLIES
7.5K
VIEWS

Format as a fraction without interpreting it as a mathematical fraction?

QUESTION FROM: Anonymous User | 8 years ago BY: Sander Huisman
Presentation and Notebooks , User Interface , Wolfram Language
5
REPLIES
5.4K
VIEWS

Is there a way to have Mathematica ignore images when saving notebooks?

QUESTION FROM: Richard Hennigan | 10 years ago BY: Sebastian Starosielec
Authoring and Publishing , Graphics and Visualization , ...
3
REPLIES
24.3K
VIEWS

Slide show preparation and presentation tips

QUESTION FROM: Jay Gourley | 4 months ago BY: Michael Rogers
Presentation and Notebooks , Wolfram Language
4
REPLIES
1.6K
VIEWS

Changing the Notebook Stylesheet

QUESTION FROM: John Steigerwalt | 8 months ago BY: Paul Nielan
Mathematica , Presentation and Notebooks , User Interface
12
REPLIES
13.8K
VIEWS

Where are notebooks for "Classical Mechanics with Mathematica", 2nd ed?

QUESTION FROM: Murray Eisenberg | 4 years ago BY: Raspi Rascal
Authoring and Publishing , Mathematica , Mathematics , Physics , ...
10
REPLIES
18.7K
VIEWS

Version 12.1 Default FontSize

QUESTION FROM: Werner Geiger | 5 years ago BY: Jos Klaps
Mathematica , Presentation and Notebooks , User Interface
21
REPLIES
20K
VIEWS

How to get the output width of text?

QUESTION FROM: Werner Geiger | 5 years ago BY: Neil Singer
Presentation and Notebooks , User Interface , Wolfram Language
9
REPLIES
7.7K
VIEWS

Free Wolfram Engine for Developers: What editor or IDE do you use?

QUESTION FROM: Arnoud Buzing | 6 years ago BY: Nicola Cattabiani
External Programs and Systems , Packages , ...
4
REPLIES
13.2K
VIEWS

Any suggestions for displaying text Grid with Overlay plot?

QUESTION FROM: diller ryan | 7 years ago BY: Jos Klaps
Authoring and Publishing , Graphics and Visualization , ...
6
REPLIES
12.6K
VIEWS

Move Notebook-Cell Brackets to the Left of the Window?

QUESTION FROM: Anonymous User | 7 years ago BY: Gustavo Delfino
Mathematica , Presentation and Notebooks , User Interface , ...
3
REPLIES
6.4K
VIEWS

Can Wolfram Desktop open a second window on the same notebook?

QUESTION FROM: Werner Geiger | 2 years ago BY: Werner Geiger
Mathematica , Presentation and Notebooks , User Interface
4
REPLIES
10.7K
VIEWS

How to Download notebooks from Wolfram University Courses

QUESTION FROM: Peter Burbery | 3 years ago BY: Cassidy Hinkle
Education , Presentation and Notebooks , Wolfram Language , Wolfram U
1
REPLIES
5.5K
VIEWS

[?] Use functions in WriteLine?

QUESTION FROM: Dominik Zámyslický | 6 years ago BY: Dominik Zámyslický
Natural Language Processing , Presentation and Notebooks , ...
3
REPLIES
6.8K
VIEWS

`UndocumentedTestFEParserPacket` vs. `ReparseBoxStructurePacket`?

QUESTION FROM: Robert Jacobson | 7 years ago BY: Kuba Podkalicki
Mathematica , Packages , Presentation and Notebooks , ...
1
REPLIES
7.7K
VIEWS

Present results of some calculations without using notebooks or CDF?

QUESTION FROM: Mikhail Strilnik | 7 years ago BY: Ian Williams
Authoring and Publishing , Import and Export , Mathematica , ...
8
REPLIES
10.1K
VIEWS

[?] Cell tag containing a comma?

QUESTION FROM: Imre Pazsit | 8 years ago BY: Imre Pazsit
Authoring and Publishing , Presentation and Notebooks , ...
4
REPLIES
8.7K
VIEWS

Documentation`HelpLookupPacletURI broken in 11.1, workaround?

QUESTION FROM: Szabolcs Horvát | 8 years ago BY: Szabolcs Horvát
Mathematica , Operating System and Network Access , ...
1
REPLIES
4.7K
VIEWS

[?] Export palette from Mathematica into .pal file

QUESTION FROM: Markus Schmidt | 8 years ago BY: Sander Huisman
Import and Export , Mathematica , Mathematics , Modeling , Optics , ...
5
REPLIES
11.2K
VIEWS

Improve Math display in on-line Mathematica help documentation?

QUESTION FROM: Nasser M. Abbasi | 9 years ago BY: George Woodrow III
Mathematica , Presentation and Notebooks , User Interface
2
REPLIES
7.5K
VIEWS

Global vs local variables in notebooks

QUESTION FROM: Herbert Swan | 9 years ago BY: Henrik Schachner
Mathematica , Presentation and Notebooks , Wolfram Language
3
REPLIES
9.8K
VIEWS

PlotStyle -> Thickness functions differently on Mac vs Windows

QUESTION FROM: Bryan Lettner | 9 years ago BY: Bryan Lettner
External Programs and Systems , Geometry , ...
10
REPLIES
10K
VIEWS

How can i use expressions from previous results?

QUESTION FROM: olayinka oyekola | 10 years ago BY: olayinka oyekola
Algebra , Mathematica , Presentation and Notebooks , Wolfram Language
24
REPLIES
18.7K
VIEWS

SaveAs to same folder, Word completion in Text cells.

QUESTION FROM: David J M Park Jr | 10 years ago BY: David Keith
Mathematica , Presentation and Notebooks , User Interface
4
REPLIES
10.6K
VIEWS

How Can I Password-Protect a Mathematica Notebook?

QUESTION FROM: Gregory Lypny | 11 years ago BY: Gregory Lypny
Mathematica , Presentation and Notebooks , Software Development
2
REPLIES
8.1K
VIEWS

Changing notebook menu fonts?

QUESTION FROM: Jeffrey Denison | 4 months ago BY: Ian Hojnicki
Presentation and Notebooks , User Interface , Wolfram Language
4
REPLIES
1.9K
VIEWS

Set default Chat-Notebook Model to something other than base gpt-3.5-turbo and gpt-4?

QUESTION FROM: Russell Foltz-Smith | 2 years ago BY: Russell Foltz-Smith
Computational Linguistics , Data Science , Machine Learning , ...
8
REPLIES
7.6K
VIEWS

Reset the ItemNumbered counter within a single notebook

QUESTION FROM: Jon Joseph | 2 years ago BY: Jon Joseph
Presentation and Notebooks , Wolfram Language
3
REPLIES
3.4K
VIEWS

How to set the unit system to the SI by default

QUESTION FROM: Peter Burbery | 2 years ago BY: Juan Falgueras Cano
Presentation and Notebooks , Units , Wolfram Language
8
REPLIES
4.8K
VIEWS

How to replace placeholder frame for picture in Textbook template?

QUESTION FROM: irek7 | 3 years ago BY: Larry Adelston
Graphics and Visualization , Mathematica , ...
3
REPLIES
6K
VIEWS

Equation numbering by chapters and sections

QUESTION FROM: Omar Alsuhaimi | 3 years ago BY: irek7
Authoring and Publishing , Mathematica , Mathematics , ...
6
REPLIES
15.3K
VIEWS

How to make these codes run automatically when the notebook is opened?

QUESTION FROM: Zhenyu Zeng | 3 years ago BY: Zhenyu Zeng
Presentation and Notebooks , Wolfram Language
11
REPLIES
3.9K
VIEWS

Avoid SelectionMove inconsistency?

QUESTION FROM: Alexey Popkov | 3 years ago BY: Updating Name
Mathematica , Presentation and Notebooks , Tuning and Debugging , ...
4
REPLIES
11.1K
VIEWS

Palette code doesn't work in new session?

QUESTION FROM: Andrew Meit | 4 years ago BY: Andrew Meit
Dynamic Interactivity , Interface Construction , ...
10
REPLIES
6.2K
VIEWS

Managing variable names in notebooks?

QUESTION FROM: Jay Gourley | 4 years ago BY: John Baxter
Mathematica , Presentation and Notebooks , Wolfram Language
4
REPLIES
9.3K
VIEWS

Typesetting inline math?

QUESTION FROM: Thomas Vermaak | 4 years ago BY: Thomas Vermaak
Mathematics , Presentation and Notebooks , Wolfram Language
8
REPLIES
6.7K
VIEWS

Can a Style inherit CellMargins depending how it is grouped?

QUESTION FROM: W. Craig Carter | 5 years ago BY: W. Craig Carter
Mathematica , Presentation and Notebooks , User Interface , ...
6
REPLIES
7.7K
VIEWS

Manipulates don't show their value in published notebook in WolframCloud

QUESTION FROM: Luc Barthelet | 6 years ago BY: Luc Barthelet
Presentation and Notebooks , User Interface , Wolfram Cloud , ...
4
REPLIES
10.7K
VIEWS

Download a notebook from Wolfram Foundation Notebook Archive?

QUESTION FROM: Murray Eisenberg | 6 years ago BY: EDITORIAL BOARD
Authoring and Publishing , Mathematica , Mathematics , ...
2
REPLIES
9.3K
VIEWS

Count the total number of words in a Wolfram notebook?

QUESTION FROM: Paul Davidson | 6 years ago BY: Paul Davidson
Authoring and Publishing , Natural Language Processing , ...
3
REPLIES
9.6K
VIEWS

Can examples for training be shown in the Neural Network repository?

QUESTION FROM: Carl Lange | 7 years ago BY: Carl Lange
Curated Data , Data Science , Machine Learning , Neural Networks , ...
5
REPLIES
15.4K
VIEWS

Deploy part of a notebook to a web page?

QUESTION FROM: Lawrence Berry | 7 years ago BY: Lawrence Berry
Authoring and Publishing , Presentation and Notebooks , ...
4
REPLIES
8.4K
VIEWS

Modify the theme in the Presenter Notebooks introduced in 11.2 ?

QUESTION FROM: W. Craig Carter | 7 years ago BY: W. Craig Carter
Presentation and Notebooks , User Interface , Wolfram Language
6
REPLIES
14.6K
VIEWS

[?] Edit and evaluate several scripts automatically?

QUESTION FROM: Nik Ka | 8 years ago BY: Nik Ka
Mathematica , Presentation and Notebooks , Wolfram Language
4
REPLIES
4K
VIEWS

How can you indent (CellMargin) Printout Environment styles?

QUESTION FROM: Spencer Fretwell | 8 years ago BY: Kuba Podkalicki
Authoring and Publishing , Mathematica , Presentation and Notebooks , ...
1
REPLIES
8.2K
VIEWS

Create a publication quality document in Mathematica?

QUESTION FROM: mdkimzey Kimzey | 8 years ago BY: David J M Park Jr
Authoring and Publishing , Mathematica , Presentation and Notebooks , ...
5
REPLIES
23.7K
VIEWS

Remote kernels, Neural Networks and formatting of Dynamic content

QUESTION FROM: Flip Phillips | 8 years ago BY: Flip Phillips
Data Science , Dynamic Interactivity , High-Performance Computing , ...
2
REPLIES
13.9K
VIEWS

Where can I download more gems (notebooks) like this one?

QUESTION FROM: Ali Hashmi | 8 years ago BY: Anonymous User
Education , Presentation and Notebooks , Wolfram Language
4
REPLIES
12.7K
VIEWS

Make an index with a popup menu?

QUESTION FROM: W Mora | 8 years ago BY: W Mora
Authoring and Publishing , Dynamic Interactivity , ...
2
REPLIES
7K
VIEWS

Reduce a Mathematica Notebook file size?

QUESTION FROM: Christopher Fox | 9 years ago BY: Sam Carrettie
Mathematica , Optimization , Presentation and Notebooks
6
REPLIES
17.5K
VIEWS

Geostatistics - Wolfram library document does not work/no alternatives?

QUESTION FROM: Malcolm Davidson | 9 years ago BY: Sam Carrettie
Computable Document Format , Earth Science , ...
2
REPLIES
10.6K
VIEWS

StyleSheets from scratch: Documentation on CellGroupingRules?

QUESTION FROM: W. Craig Carter | 9 years ago BY: Alexey Popkov
Interface Construction , Mathematica , Presentation and Notebooks
4
REPLIES
11.5K
VIEWS

File corrupted

QUESTION FROM: Cleuzir da Luz | 11 years ago BY: Jesse Friedman
Mathematica , Presentation and Notebooks
5
REPLIES
21.2K
VIEWS

How do I get quotes out of this Grid?

QUESTION FROM: david.a.wagner | 12 years ago BY: Vitaliy Kaurov
Mathematica , Presentation and Notebooks , Wolfram Language
4
REPLIES
5K
VIEWS
1
2
3
4
5

Group Count Group Count

427 Discussions

Group Branding Group Branding

New Discussion New Discussion

ACTIVE MEMBERS ACTIVE MEMBERS

ACTIVE MEMBERS
danielscarvalho
Daniel Carvalho
15 days ago
russell
Gareth Russell
3 days ago
adeyoung
Andrew D
1 month ago
btedesco2241
Bruce Tedesco
2 months ago
gag0002
Gilmer Gary
5 days ago
ivanovdenis710616
Denis Ivanov
3 months ago
jgourle2
Jay Gourley
5 months ago

RELATED GROUPS RELATED GROUPS

RELATED GROUPS
Wolfram Language 11K discussions 2K subscriptions
Wolfram|Alpha 895 discussions 1K subscriptions
Events & Media 1K discussions 923 subscriptions
Machine Learning 984 discussions 1K subscriptions
Wolfram Cloud 638 discussions 660 subscriptions